Fit Butter vs Standard Peanut Butter: Protein, Sugar and Flavor Compared (Canada 2026)
Is Fit Butter better than regular peanut butter? On the numbers that matter for a high-protein snack, yes. Fit Butter adds whey or plant protein to dry-roasted nuts for 7-8 g protein and just 0-2 g added sugar per 2-tbsp serving — matching natural peanut butter on protein while beating sweetened, dessert-style spreads on sugar.
The quick verdict
Plain natural peanut butter is a great, simple staple and we are not knocking it. But if you want dessert-style flavor and functional macros in the same jar, Fit Butter is the honest upgrade — same protein as natural PB, a bump from added whey or plant protein, and a fraction of the sugar of most flavored spreads. Our top pick to start is Fit Butter in a peanut-based flavor (8 g protein per serving).
How they compare (per 2 tbsp)
| Spread | Protein | Added sugar | Protein source | Flavor range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fit Butter | 7-8 g | 0-2 g | Nuts + whey / plant protein | 8 dessert flavors |
| Natural peanut butter (just nuts + salt) | ~7-8 g | 0 g | Peanuts only | Plain |
| Typical sweetened / flavored spread | ~3-5 g | ~5 g or more | Nuts + added sugar | Varies |
Peanut-butter and sweetened-spread figures are typical category values for a 2-tbsp serving and vary by brand — always check the label on the product you buy. Fit Butter figures are from the jar's Nutrition Facts panel.
What makes Fit Butter different
Every jar is churned in small batches from dry-roasted nuts (cashew, almond and/or peanut depending on the flavor), a scoop of whey or plant protein, coconut oil for a smooth texture, and real mix-ins like cookie pieces, marshmallow or chocolate chips. So a spoonful tastes like Birthday Cake, S'mores or Cookie Dough while eating like a high-protein snack — 0-2 g added sugar, not the 5 g-plus you often find in dessert spreads.
Allergens and diets
Most flavors contain milk (from whey) and soy. Peanut-based flavors contain peanuts; Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, JET-PUFFED S'mores and White Chocolate Macadamia contain wheat (not gluten-free), and White Chocolate Macadamia also contains eggs. Only Cinnamon Sugar Cookie is vegan and dairy-free (tree nuts only). Always check the individual jar.
Browse the lineup — add to cart in one tap
We are a Montreal-based specialty retailer and have hand-picked better-for-you supplements and snacks since 2016. Order early and we offer same-day shipping from Montreal, and we ship across Canada with UPS, GLS, Canada Post, ITS, Canpar, Purolator and FedEx — with free shipping on qualifying orders.
Rated 4.9/5 on Google (343 reviews) and 4.87/5 on Judge.me across 565 store reviews, from a community of tens of thousands of Canadian customers served since 2016.
FAQ
Does Fit Butter have more protein than regular peanut butter?
They are close on protein — natural peanut butter has about 7-8 g per 2 tbsp and Fit Butter has 7-8 g — but Fit Butter adds whey or plant protein and keeps added sugar to 0-2 g, whereas many flavored or sweetened spreads add far more sugar.
Is Fit Butter lower in sugar than sweetened nut butters?
Yes. Fit Butter carries only 0-2 g of added sugar per 2-tbsp serving, well below typical dessert-flavored or sweetened spreads that can run 5 g or more of added sugar.
Which Fit Butter flavor is vegan or gluten-free?
Only Cinnamon Sugar Cookie is vegan and dairy-free. It is also one of the flavors without wheat; Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, JET-PUFFED S'mores and White Chocolate Macadamia contain wheat, so check the label if you avoid gluten.
Where can I buy Fit Butter in Canada?
Top Nutrition & Fitness stocks Fit Butter and ships across Canada from Montreal, with free shipping on qualifying orders.
En français — Fit Butter vs beurre d'arachide ordinaire
Le beurre d'arachide naturel est un excellent classique, mais si vous voulez un goût de dessert et de bonnes macros dans le même pot, Fit Butter est la vraie amélioration : 7 à 8 g de protéines et seulement 0 à 2 g de sucre ajouté par portion de 2 c. à soupe, grâce à la protéine de lactosérum ou végétale ajoutée aux noix rôties. Huit saveurs gourmandes. La plupart contiennent du lait et du soya; seule la saveur Cinnamon Sugar Cookie est végane. Expédition partout au Canada depuis Montréal, depuis 2016.
Shop protected with Onward
At checkout you can choose "Checkout+ Now" to add Onward package protection and cashback, or "Continue without Benefits" to check out as usual. Onward is an opt-in upgrade no other Canadian retailer offers — your call, every order.
