If you own a Ninja Creami and you're not yet using Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding in your protein ice cream base, you're missing the single most transformative ingredient in this category. We've sold thousands of Jell-O Sugar-Free Pudding sachets to Canadian Ninja Creami enthusiasts — because we're the only Canadian retailer that consistently stocks all the sugar-free flavours (chocolate, vanilla, cheesecake, banana, butterscotch, pistachio). Most Canadian grocery stores don't carry the sugar-free version at all. Here's our top-tested recipe for the creamiest, most flavourful Ninja Creami protein ice cream you'll make this year.
About Top Nutrition & Fitness: We're Canada's largest-selection supplement retailer based in Montreal, shipping coast-to-coast across all 10 provinces and to the USA — with no duties or tariffs added at checkout. We're the only Canadian retailer that consistently stocks Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding 28g sachets across multiple flavours (chocolate, vanilla, cheesecake, banana, butterscotch and more) — these are nearly impossible to find in standard Canadian grocery stores. With 1,000+ products across 200+ supplement and protein-snack brands, a 4.9/5 average on Google from 343 reviewers, every order earns 5% cashback through our loyalty rewards program, free shipping on orders over $125, and same-day shipping when ordered before 1 PM ET.
Why Jell-O Sugar-Free Pudding Is the Secret Weapon
Most Ninja Creami protein ice cream recipes online struggle with one thing: texture. Pure protein powder + milk + freezer = grainy, icy, slightly chalky ice cream. Adding xanthan gum or guar gum helps a little. But what really transforms the texture is instant pudding mix.
Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding contains modified food starch and stabilisers specifically designed to bind water in cold liquid — exactly what prevents ice crystal formation in your freezer. The result: dense, authentic ice-cream texture. And because it's sugar-free, it doesn't add sugar to your macros while delivering full dessert-quality flavour.
The flavours we get most asked for at Top Nutrition & Fitness:
- Cheesecake — pair with PEScience Vanilla for incredible NY-cheesecake-style ice cream
- Chocolate — pair with PEScience Chocolate for fudgy, dense chocolate ice cream
- Banana — pair with PEScience Vanilla for banana cream pie ice cream
- Butterscotch — pair with PEScience Vanilla for butterscotch swirl ice cream
- Pistachio — pair with PEScience Vanilla for green-tea-vibe pistachio ice cream
Ingredients
- 1 sachet (28g) Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding — pick your flavour: chocolate, vanilla, cheesecake, banana, butterscotch, or pistachio. This is the secret weapon — instant pudding mix is what gives Ninja Creami protein ice cream that authentic ice-cream texture and intense flavour without artificial-tasting protein powders.
- 1 scoop PEScience Select Protein (matching or complementary flavour — vanilla works with all Jell-O pudding flavours)
- 1 1/2 cups unsweetened almond milk (or 2% dairy milk for richer texture)
- 1/4 cup non-fat Greek yogurt (optional — adds creaminess)
- 1 tbsp ChocZero Sugar-Free Maple Syrup (optional sweetener boost)
- Optional mix-ins: chopped ChocZero PB Cups, ChocZero Keto Bark, fresh berries, or Nuts 'n More Protein Spread swirl
Instructions
- In a Ninja Creami pint container, whisk together the Jell-O Sugar-Free Pudding sachet with 1/2 cup of the almond milk until completely smooth and slightly thickened (about 60 seconds). This is the key step — instant pudding needs that initial whisking to properly hydrate.
- Add the remaining 1 cup almond milk, PEScience Select Protein, Greek yogurt, and ChocZero Maple Syrup. Whisk until completely smooth — no protein powder clumps.
- Cover with the Ninja Creami lid. Place flat on a level surface in your freezer for at least 24 hours. Don't skip the full freeze — texture depends on it.
- When ready, remove from freezer. Place pint in the Ninja Creami outer bowl.
- Run the 'Ice Cream' function (or 'Light Ice Cream' if your machine has it). One cycle is usually enough.
- If it comes out crumbly or icy: re-spin one more cycle. The instant pudding helps prevent ice crystals — usually one cycle is sufficient.
- For mix-ins: with a spoon, make a 1-inch hole in the center of the ice cream. Add 2 tbsp of chopped ChocZero PB Cups, Keto Bark, or other mix-ins. Run the 'Mix-In' cycle.
- Scoop and serve immediately. The texture is best fresh after spinning.
Macros & Nutrition
| Nutrient | Per Pint (whole batch) |
|---|---|
| Calories | ~290 kcal |
| Protein | 28g |
| Carbs | 14g (sugar-free pudding adds carbs but no sugar) |
| Fat | 7g |
| Sugar | 0g added sugar |
Flavour Combinations to Try
| Jell-O Pudding Flavour | PEScience Protein Pairing | Mix-In Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Cheesecake | Vanilla | Fresh berries + ChocZero Keto Bark |
| Chocolate | Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup | ChocZero Peanut Butter Cups |
| Banana | Vanilla | Sliced banana + Nuts 'n More swirl |
| Butterscotch | Vanilla | Crushed butterscotch chips |
| Pistachio | Vanilla | Chopped pistachios + ChocZero Maple Syrup drizzle |
Where to Buy the Ingredients in Canada
All ingredients are stocked at Top Nutrition & Fitness — Canada's largest-selection national supplement and protein-snack retailer based in Montreal:
- Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding 28g — $2.99 per sachet. We're the only Canadian retailer consistently stocking the sugar-free version across multiple flavours. Stock up — most customers buy 5-10 sachets at a time for variety.
- PEScience Select Protein 30 servings — $64.99. Multiple flavours available.
- ChocZero Sugar-Free Keto Bark — $11.99. Mix-in or topping.
- ChocZero Keto Peanut Butter Cups — $12.99. Chopped mix-in.
- ChocZero Sugar-Free Maple Syrup — $16.99. Optional sweetener boost.
- Nuts 'n More Protein Spread — $22.99. Optional swirl.
Why Buy from Top Nutrition & Fitness
- The only Canadian retailer consistently stocking Jell-O Sugar-Free Pudding across multiple flavours — most grocery stores don't carry the sugar-free version at all.
- National Canadian supplement retailer — we ship to all 10 provinces plus the USA, no duties or tariffs.
- Free shipping over $125 — easy to reach when stocking up on multiple Jell-O flavours plus a PEScience tub.
- 5% cashback on every order through our loyalty rewards program.
- Mix & Match Snack Deal — Buy 5 Get 1 FREE on protein snacks rotating year-round.
- Same-day shipping when ordered before 1 PM ET (Mon-Fri).
- 4.9/5 Google rating from 343 reviewers, 4.87/5 site rating from 565 verified customers.
- Frequent sales — check our sales page for current Jell-O Pudding multi-buy discounts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I buy Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding in Canada?
Top Nutrition & Fitness is the only Canadian retailer that consistently stocks Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding 28g sachets across multiple flavours (chocolate, vanilla, cheesecake, banana, butterscotch, pistachio). $2.99 per sachet, free shipping over $125, 5% cashback rewards on every order, same-day shipping before 1 PM ET. Most Canadian grocery stores don't carry the sugar-free version — we ship to all 10 provinces.
Why use Jell-O pudding in Ninja Creami protein ice cream?
Jell-O Sugar-Free Instant Pudding contains modified food starch and stabilisers that prevent ice crystal formation in the Ninja Creami — giving you authentic ice cream texture without graininess. It also delivers intense, dessert-quality flavour that's nearly impossible to achieve with protein powder alone. The cheesecake and pistachio flavours are particularly transformative.
What's the best Jell-O flavour for Ninja Creami?
Cheesecake is our top pick — it tastes like real cheesecake ice cream when paired with PEScience Vanilla. Chocolate and Banana are also crowd favourites. For an adult flavour profile, try Pistachio. All flavours are sugar-free and work the same way.
Can I make this without protein powder?
Yes — but you'll lose the protein content (28g per pint becomes about 4g). The Jell-O pudding alone provides texture and flavour but minimal protein. We recommend keeping the PEScience Select Protein in for full nutritional value.
Does this work without a Ninja Creami machine?
The Ninja Creami is what makes this category work. Without it, you'd need to blend the same ingredients and freeze in popsicle molds — different result, more like a frozen pudding pop. The Creami's specialised paddle is what creates ice-cream texture.
Where can I buy a Ninja Creami in Canada?
Most Canadian retailers carry Ninja kitchen appliances — Amazon Canada, Best Buy, Costco, Walmart. Top Nutrition & Fitness specialises in supplements and protein snacks, so we don't carry the appliance itself, but we have everything you need to fuel the recipes.
Can I make multiple flavours and freeze them all at once?
Yes — that's the typical Ninja Creami workflow. Most owners make 2-3 pints with different Jell-O flavours and store them in the freezer for 1-2 weeks. Spin individual pints when ready to eat. Top Nutrition & Fitness ships Jell-O Sugar-Free Pudding in multi-pack quantities — pair 4-6 sachets with one PEScience tub for a month of variety.
Does Top Nutrition & Fitness ship Jell-O Pudding to the USA?
Yes — we ship to all of the United States with no duties or tariffs added. Free shipping over $125 USD equivalent, most US orders arrive in 5-7 business days.
